Dump, date, or marry: Romantic comedy edition

We’ve all played dump, date or marry at some point in our lives. It never really gets old, does it? With that in mind, we’ve got a good one for you. Which one of these romantic comedy heroes would you dump, date, or marry? We’ve got our answers, even though it was anything but easy to decide ...

The choices:

​So, here it goes...

Dump

via GIPHY

So, this one is super painful, because I love all of these heroes in a way that probably borders on unnatural. But...with great sadness, I must break up with...Dominic from By A Thread. Because even though I loved him dearly, and even though the grumpy ones are my catnip, I'm letting him go simply because I can't let the other two go. There's literally nothing wrong with Dominic. I just love Jude and Nick a little more. But that doesn't mean I won't cry a little (or a lot) over the loss of Dominic...  

Date

via GIPHY

I'm gonna have to go with Jude from The Mogul and the Muscle on this one. As I mentioned in my review of the book, he's beyond adorable. He's also mature, not at all threatened by super successful women, and is a kick ass bodyguard (which I think would come in handy to have around these days, especially at the grocery store where the cleaning products aisle sometimes feels like a war zone). There's no way I couldn't at the VERY least take Jude out for a test drive (so to speak...ahem).   

Marry

via GIPHY

The dall, dark, and fictional man on this list that I would choose to spend eternity with is Nick from You Complicate Me.  While all the men on this list have a lot going for them (looks, witty banter, respect for women), Nick has two additional things that tipped the scales in his favor. Number 1: he's described as looking like Hugh Jackman's younger, hotter, blue-eyed brother, and I've been absurdly fascinated with Hugh Jackman since he first appeared as Wolverine a crap-ton of years ago. And Number 2: Snark. No one on this list can snark the way Nick can, and in my opinion, every relationship can benefit from a daily dose of snark. 

But what about you? Which of these book boyfriends would you dump, date, and marry?